Science News

Share   Blog   Cite

Print   Email   Bookmark

Psychiatry's Main Method to Prevent Mistaken Diagnoses of Depression Doesn't Work: Study

ScienceDaily (Feb. 25, 2010) — A study in the March edition of the American Journal of Psychiatry senior-authored by Jerome C. Wakefield, a professor at the Silver School of Social Work at New York University with Mark Schmitz of Temple University and Judith Baer of Rutgers University, empirically challenges the effectiveness of psychiatrists' official diagnostic manual in preventing mistaken, false-positive diagnoses of depression.

See Also:

Health & Medicine

Mental Health Research

Diseases and Conditions

Workplace Health

Mind & Brain

Depression

Mental Health

Psychiatry

Reference

Personality disorder

Psychopathology

Substance abuse

Adult attention-deficit disorder

The findings concerning the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders' (DSM) criteria for diagnosing depression rebuts recent criticism of earlier research by Wakefield. That earlier research suggested that misdiagnoses of depression are widespread, and touched off considerable controversy.

According to the DSM, the diagnosis of major depression requires the presence -- for two weeks -- of at least five possible symptoms out of a list of nine, which include, for example, sadness, loss of interest in usual activities, lowered appetite, fatigue, and insomnia. However, these symptoms can also occur in normal responses to loss and stress. False positive diagnoses occur when someone reacting with intense normal sadness to life's stresses is misdiagnosed as having major depressive disorder. Recent studies suggest that a very large percentage of people have such symptoms for two weeks or longer at some point in their lives; therefore, how many of these individuals really are afflicted by a mental disorder or are responding within normal limits to loss or stress has been a matter of debate.

The journal article examines the primary method by which the official diagnostic criteria for depression -the Clinical Significance Criterion (CSC) -- are supposed to distinguish normal from disordered cases and thereby prevent false positive diagnoses. The CSC was added to the symptom and duration criteria in the DSM's fourth edition in 1994 (DSM-IV) in the wake of criticism that too many of the listed symptoms -- loss of appetite, say, or sadness, insomnia, or fatigue -- were being identified as evidence of major depressive disorder even when they were mild and possibly normal responses to distress arising from such events as the loss of a job, the dissolution of a marriage, or other triggers for sadness, and that such errors might be contributing to the very high reported rates of untreated depression in the American population drawn from epidemiological surveys.

Under the 1994 DSM revision, in addition to the two weeks of sadness and other depressive symptoms, a specified minimal "clinically significant" threshold in the form of harm due to distress or role impairment (in occupational, family, or interpersonal contexts) must have resulted from the symptoms in evidence before they could be considered signs of depression. Researchers have subsequently assumed -- without definitive evidence -- that the CSC eliminates substantial numbers of false positives.

In a 1999 article in American Journal of Psychiatry, Wakefield and co-author Robert Spitzer, the originator of the modern DSM symptom-based approach to diagnosis, argued that the CSC would not eliminate false-positive diagnoses of major depression because anyone having the specified symptoms -- even an individual experiencing a normal intense reaction to loss -- would be likely to experience distress or role impairment. Thus, they asserted, the CSC was redundant with the symptom criteria and could not distinguish normal from disordered symptoms -- a claim that has come to be known as the "redundancy hypothesis." The researchers' argument was purely conceptual, and largely ignored.

The issue of whether the redundancy hypothesis is correct became suddenly more important after Wakefield senior-authored a much-discussed 2007 article in Archives of General Psychiatry. The article argued that there were indeed large numbers of false-positive diagnoses of major depression in community surveys of mental disorder -- possibly as high as 25% to 33%. However, that study used data from a national survey that was conducted before the DSM-IV's addition of the CSC to the major depression diagnostic criteria. Thus, there was no CSC in the criteria that Wakefield and his team used to identify cases of major depression at the time.

Critics of that study argued that the lack of a CSC was fatal to the argument because if the CSC had been used, then the supposed false-positive diagnoses that Wakefield and his group identified would likely have been eliminated as cases too mild for diagnosis. For example, one noted psychiatrist argued that Wakefield's results were due to a "glitch" in the diagnostic criteria Wakefield used, and that the diagnosed individuals identified by Wakefield as having normal reactions would have been eliminated from the depression category if current diagnostic criteria including the CSC were used.

A paper later submitted by Wakefield that built on the 2007 article was rejected for publication partly based on a reviewer's assertion that if the CSC had been included in the earlier study, the supposed false positives likely would have been eliminated. So, the issue of whether the CSC is in fact redundant or actually eliminated many false-positive major depression diagnoses became key to the debate, which is still ongoing, about the prevalence of depressive disorder.

The latest study, coming in the American Journal of Psychiatry, offers an empirical demonstration, based on nationally representative data, that the Critical Significance Criterion fails to distinguish normal from disordered conditions. In this analysis, Wakefield undertook to evaluate independently the impact of the CSC on epidemiological survey estimates of major depressive disorder by using data from a later survey that included a carefully worked out CSC criterion for depression whose inclusion, according to the claims of its authors, was an effective way of eliminating former false positives. Wakefield then compared estimates of depressive disorder with and without the use of the CSC.

Confirming the redundancy hypothesis put forward a decade earlier, he found that the CSC eliminated virtually no one from diagnosis -- in fact, even among those who experienced prolonged sadness without meeting other diagnostic criteria for depression, about 94% of them satisfied the CSC just on the basis of the "distress" component alone. Thus the Clinical Significance Criterion, according to Wakefield and his co-authors, is not doing what it is supposed to do -- reducing the over-diagnosis of normal mood fluctuations as depression -- and the issue of preventing false positives needs to be revisited. And contrary to critics' speculations, the earlier findings suggesting many false positives in community surveys cannot be dismissed on the basis of the CSC.

The results take on further importance, Wakefield says, in light of proposals for changes to the DSM in a revision currently taking place that will lead to DSM-V. Concern about increasing false positives is at the heart of criticisms of the proposals that have been put forward by leading psychiatrists, including Allen Frances, the Editor of DSM-IV. Moreover, some of the proposals seem to rely heavily on the CSC to justify diagnosis of disorder even when symptoms are minimal -- when in fact the current research underscores that normal distress can easily satisfy the CSC.

Email or share this story:

| More

Story Source:

Adapted from materials provided by New York University.

Journal Reference:

Jerome C. Wakefield, Mark F. Schmitz, Judith C. Baer. Does the DSM-IV Clinical Significance Criterion for Major Depression Reduce False Positives? Evidence From the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. American Journal of Psychiatry, 2010; DOI: 10.1176/appi.ajp.2009.09040553

Need to cite this story in your essay, paper, or report? Use one of the following formats:

APA

MLA

Note: If no author is given, the source is cited instead.

Related Stories

Errors In Diagnosis Of Depression Lead To Over And Under Diagnosis In Primary Care (Aug. 3, 2009) — A meta-analysis of more than 50,000 patients has shown that general practitioners have great difficulty separating those with and without depression, with substantial numbers of missed and ...  > read more

Many Physicians Not Using Established Criteria When Diagnosing Major Depressive Disorder in Patients, Study Finds (Feb. 2, 2010) — A new study indicates that a majority of non-psychiatrist physicians and a substantial minority of psychiatrists reported that they often do not use the criteria outlined in the Diagnostic and ...  > read more

Depression And Anxiety Disorders Of Adolescents Are Not The Same Thing (Sep. 24, 2009) — Adolescent depression and anxiety disorders are two distinct psychiatric disorders, according to a recent ...  > read more

Successful Treatment Of Mothers With Depression Helps Their Children, Too (Mar. 23, 2006) — Children whose mothers are depressed are more likely to suffer from anxiety, mental-health problems and disruptive behavior than those whose moms aren't. And if the mothers don't get better, these ...  > read more

Diagnoses Of Fatigue In Primary Care Patients (Oct. 26, 2009) — Patients who visit their family doctors for fatigue have a wide range of diagnoses yet the prevalence of serious illness was low, according to a Dutch ...  > read more

Elderly Most at Risk for Major Depression Identified (Dec. 22, 2009) — Researchers have pinpointed the prime factors identifying which elderly persons are at the highest risk for developing major ...  > read more

Is There A Developmental Component To The Risk For Depression? (Dec. 11, 2007) — Psychiatrists remain divided as to how to define and classify the mood and anxiety disorders, the most common mental disorders. Authors of a new study explain that their findings support a proposed ...  > read more

Using Genetics To Improve Traditional Psychiatric Diagnoses (July 17, 2008) — Psychiatry has begun the laborious effort of preparing the DSM-V, the new iteration of its diagnostic manual. In so doing, it once again wrestles with the task set by Carl Linnaeus, to "cleave nature ...  > read more

Search ScienceDaily

Number of stories in archives: 82,027

Find with keyword(s):

Enter a keyword or phrase to search ScienceDaily's archives for related news topics,
the latest news stories, reference articles, science videos, images, and books.

Just In:
Fossils Reveal Plankton-Eating Giant Fish

Babies, Even When Premature, 'See' With Hands

Warming Likely To Affect Tropical Rainfall

Quake Hits Chile, Triggers Tsunami

Can Math and Science Help Solve Crimes?

Coral Develops 'Skills' to Cope With Warming

Threat to Monkey Numbers from Forest Decline

'Alien Invaders' Found in Milky Way

Science Video News

Lost And Found

Cognitive scientists ran an experiment to understand how the brain searches for an object with a known shape. They asked subjects to track the. ...  > full story

Psychiatrists Can Predict Onset of Alzheimer's with New EEG Test

Neurologists Use New Brain Scanning Device To Better Control Seizures

Civil Engineers Design Walk Through Butterfly Museum Exhibit

more science videos

Breaking News

... from NewsDaily.com

King Tut's grandfather's statue head surfaces in Luxor

U.N. to create science panel to review IPCC

World warming unhindered by cold spells: scientists

Losing Google would hit Chinese science hard

Woman has 2 babies in first for ovarian transplant

more science news

In Other News ...

Obama's Democrats voice new confidence on healthcare

Quake, tsunamis kill more than 700 in Chile

Storms rip through Europe, kill up to 50 in France

Violence flares at Jerusalem holy site

Jay Leno returns to TV to regain late-night crown

Clinton headed for Chile after quake

Hamas man was drugged before murder: Dubai police

Yemen arrests 21 in south

more top news

Copyright Reuters 2008. See Restrictions.

Free Subscriptions

... from ScienceDaily

Get the latest science news with our free email newsletters, updated daily and weekly. Or view hourly updated newsfeeds in your RSS reader:

Email Newsletters

RSS Newsfeeds

Feedback

... we want to hear from you!

Tell us what you think of the new ScienceDaily -- we welcome both positive and negative comments. Have any problems using the site? Questions?

Your Name:

Your Email:

Comments:

Click button to submit feedback:

About This Site  |  Editorial Staff  |  Awards & Reviews  |  Contribute News  |  Advertise With Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
Copyright © 1995-2009 ScienceDaily LLC  —  All rights reserved  —  Contact: [email-masked]
Part of the iVillage Your Total Health Network

Health & Medicine

Allergy

Alternative Medicine

Bird Flu

Birth Control

Breast Cancer

Cancer

Diabetes

Diet and Weight Loss

Diseases and Conditions

Fitness

Gene Therapy

Heart Disease

HIV and AIDS

Lung Cancer

Men's Health

Nutrition

Obesity

Pharmacology

Pregnancy and Childbirth

Sexual Health

Skin Care

Stem Cells

Women's Health

... more topics

Mind & Brain

ADD and ADHD

Addiction

Alzheimer's

Anxiety

Autism

Depression

Gender Difference

Headaches

Insomnia

Intelligence

Language Acquisition

Parkinson's

Perception

Psychology

Relationships

Schizophrenia

Social Psychology

... more topics

Plants & Animals

Agriculture and Food

Animals

Behavior

Biology

Biotechnology

Cell Biology

Cloning

Developmental Biology

Dogs

Dolphins and Whales

Endangered Animals

Extinction

Frogs and Reptiles

Genetically Modified

Marine Biology

Microbes and More

Nature

New Species

Pests and Parasites

Spiders

Zoology

... more topics

Earth & Climate

Air Quality

Climate

Coral Reefs

Earthquakes

Ecology

Environmental Science

Geography

Geology

Global Warming

Hurricanes and Cyclones

Ice Ages

Oceanography

Ozone Holes

Pollution

Renewable Energy

Tsunamis

Weather

Wildfires

... more topics

Space & Time

Astronomy

Astrophysics

Big Bang

Black Holes

Dark Matter

ESA

Extrasolar Planets

Mars

Moon

NASA

Pluto

Saturn

Solar System

Space Missions

Space Station

Space Telescopes

Stars

Sun

... more topics

Matter & Energy

Alternative Fuels

Aviation

Biochemistry

Biometric

Chemistry

Detectors

Electronics

Energy Technology

Forensics

Fossil Fuels

Inorganic Chemistry

Nanotechnology

Organic Chemistry

Physics

Quantum Physics

Solar Energy

Technology

Wind Energy

... more topics

Computers & Math

Artificial Intelligence

Communications

Computer Graphics

Computer Modeling

Computer Science

Encryption

Hacking

Mathematics

Quantum Computers

Robotics

Software

Statistics

Video Games

Virtual Reality

... more topics

Fossils & Ruins

Ancient Civilizations

Anthropology

Archaeology

Dinosaurs

Early Climate

Early Humans

Early Mammals

Evolution

Human Evolution

Lost Treasures

Origin of Life

Paleontology

Tyrannosaurus Rex

... more topics

News

Front Page

Today's Summaries

Latest Headlines

Search Archives

Email Newsletters

RSS Newsfeeds

News Sections

Health & Medicine

Mind & Brain

Plants & Animals

Space & Time

Earth & Climate

Matter & Energy

Computers & Math

Fossils & Ruins

Articles

Health & Medicine

Mind & Brain

Plants & Animals

Space & Time

Earth & Climate

Matter & Energy

Computers & Math

Fossils & Ruins

Videos

Health & Medicine

Mind & Brain

Plants & Animals

Space & Time

Earth & Climate

Matter & Energy

Computers & Math

Fossils & Ruins

Images

Health & Medicine

Mind & Brain

Plants & Animals

Space & Time

Earth & Climate

Matter & Energy

Computers & Math

Fossils & Ruins

Books

Health & Medicine

Mind & Brain

Plants & Animals

Space & Time

Earth & Climate

Matter & Energy

Computers & Math

Fossils & Ruins

Post this page to your favorite social bookmarking site:

close

del.icio.us

Digg

Furl

Netscape

Yahoo! My Web

StumbleUpon

Google Bookmarks

Technorati

BlinkList

Newsvine

ma.gnolia

reddit

Facebook

Tailrank

Slashdot

Fark

Include this item in your blog or web site:

close

Title:

Link:

Summary:

Click button to copy above text for pasting into your site:

Cite this article in your essay, paper, or report:

close

APA style:

MLA style:

Click button to copy above text for pasting into your document:

Email this page's link to a friend or colleague:

close

To Email:

Your Name:

Your Email:

cc to self